Thursday, August 12, 2010

ORIGINALITY

Dear diary,

I started my day by attending a 2-hour seminar organized by the Learning Development Centre from 10.30am-12.30pm today. It is a free course listed in the Higher Degree Research (HDR) Student Seminar Series for Spring Session 2010. The seminar is mainly about thesis writing process and the idea is to provide further details on what a thesis is all about? Sounds boring huh?? Tapi seminar ni sangat-sangat la berguna untuk student yang sedang buat PhD atau Master (by research) or sape2 je yang tengah tulis thesis.

I'm not gonna elaborate more on the whole contents of the seminar. But I found one part of it to be very very useful so it triggers me to share this with anybody who's currently doing research or has future plan in conducting a research. Senang cerita, sape2 yang sedang buat atau ade plan nak buat PhD or Master(by research), this might be an important information for you..

We were given a list of criterion and we need to state whether all the items in the list represent originality or not. Maybe you can try your own answer while reading through these.

IS THIS "ORIGINALITY"??
  1. Presenting a major piece of new information in writing for the first time
  2. Extending, qualifying or elaborating on existing piece of work
  3. Undertaking an original piece of work designed by someone else
  4. Developing a new product or improving an existing one
  5. Reinterprating an existing theory, maybe in different context
  6. Demonstrating originality by testing someone else's idea
  7. Carrying out empirical work that has not been done before
  8. Using a different methodological approach to address a problem
  9. Synthesising information in a new different way
  10. Providing a new interpretation using existing/ known information
  11. Repeating research in other contexts, for example in a different country
  12. Applying existing ideas to new areas of study
  13. Taking a particular technique and applying it in a new area
  14. Developing a new research tool or technique
  15. Taking a different approach, for example a cross-disciplinary perspective
  16. Developing a portfolio of work based on research
  17. Adding to knowledge in a way that has not been done before
  18. Conducting a study on a previously unresearched area or topic
  19. Producing a critical analysis of something not previously examined
Much to my surprise that all the answers are YES. They are all representing originality in their own way. So, look at your topic, if it fits any of the above criterion, meaning that you are doing well. Owh, just another little information for me to share, doing a PhD is not necessarily to come out with something TOTALLY NEW. That is not the whole idea. What we are doing is, find a topic, give a little bit of extension to it, solve the problem in our own context, get the result, compare it with others or previous works, if everything comes in good agreement, tadaaaaa!! the PhD is all yours!! =))

p/s: Ha, cakap memang senang kan, cuba buat dulu, baru tau langit tinggi ke rendah. It looks simple in here, but the process normally takes you years of entangle commitment. Remember, you are not doing something that is gonna change the whole world!! It is just one little tiny original and significant contribution to knowledge". Hmm, sedap sikit hati bila fikir macam tu.. So, goodluck in cruising through all your hard times yea..=))

6 comments:

myakii said...

xpaham... hahaha.....

Anonymous said...

mira...
thanks for sharing the info (knowledge)..
i tot that PhD=Totally new..;)
im not so sure when is my turn=(
OMG....doakanla yg terbaik utk ak ni ye=)
WNM..

amirah said...

hazrat:
you will need to understand this if you have plan to do research later on okay..=))

wan:
yeah,orang selalu ingat phd ni kene yang gempak2 je. konon bole merubah dunia.hehe. no, not at all. keep it narrow, and look at it in-depths. that's the idea. your turn will come soon dear, and best wishes for you..=))

firdaus said...

What a good post !!! teruskan perjuangan sis

Betul ke PHD kat australia tak perlu viva ??
Mcm mn diaorg evaluate thesis kita>??semata2 tesis ke ??

Drpd Suami Hanimah
-Firdaus Harun

amirah said...

Firdaus:
What a surprise getting a feedback from you?? Mesti anem yg bagitau kan.hehe. Literally yes, memang kat Aussie takde viva. Tapi kat sini, proposal defense sgt memainkan peranan penting utk teruskan dgn candidature.

Biasanya lepas 2 atau 3 sem, supervisor akan bgtau samada kite ready ke tak utk defense kita punya proposal, masa tu kita akan present, and ada org akan tentukan kita layak teruskan dgn projek tu atau tak. Kalau pass, maknanya selangkah dah berjaya la. Kalau tak, btolkan dulu, then baru boleh proceed. Kiranya viva diganti dgn proposal defense.

Tapi kat sini examining process agak strict. Kalau ada publish at least 3papers baru mudah sikit process. Kalau tak, panel akan banyak songeh sikit la. Tapi semua ni bergantung dekat school and faculties yang berbeza-beza sistem..

Harap explanation membantu..Good Luck!!=))

firdaus said...

ok...thanks 'Dr to be' Mira...best of luck...